Botzen Test Of Assignment Sheet

TUPE - a special assignment - how to spot those employees who transfer, those who don’t and those who might!

This article looks at 2 specific issues in the world of TUPE transfers.


This article looks at 2 specific issues in the world of TUPE transfers.

  • The definition of a service provision change and, within this, the requirement for “an organised grouping of employees…which has as its principal purpose the carrying out of activities on behalf of the client.” (Regulation 3(3)(a)(i) of TUPE)
  • Identifying whether an employee is “assigned to the organised grouping of resources or employees that is subject to the relevant transfer” (Regulation 4(1) of TUPE)

The issues are similar and closely related, but not quite the same. The first issue is a UK specific issue and only arose following the TUPE reform in 2006. The second issue is very much a European issue as the term “assignment” comes from the European Acquired Rights Directive.

These issues tend to arise as concerns at the bidding stage, when they might influence information provided by an incumbent contractor, as part of an upcoming bidding process. The issues also arise when the transferor and transferee are known and the parties attempt to reach an agreement (or not) as to what constitutes the undertaking/service which is transferring and which employees are sufficiently based in that service in order to transfer.

Issue one – what is an organised grouping of employees?

This is an essential component for a service provision change transfer. Without an organised grouping of employees there will be no service provision change. So, for example, where a team of cleaners carry out cleaning various offices belonging to different organisations, a change in cleaning contractor by one of those organisations, would not give rise to a service provision change transfer. The team does not have as its principal purpose the carrying out of activities on behalf of the client in question. Their purpose is to carry out cleaning services for a range of clients. (Note that it is theoretically possible, although unlikely, that it would give rise to a traditional transfer either)

Without a transfer then the original contractor is left with all their employees and the problem of finding them something else to do or the redundancy liabilities. Also, without an organised grouping of employees, a potential bidder, can look at a service afresh, recognising that there is not the potential restriction and cost of having to take on an existing workforce.

This issue of what amounts to an organised grouping of employees was brought in to sharp focus in 2012 in the case of Eddie Stobart Limited (“ES”) v. Moreman. This case concerned the loss of a logistics contract by ES. The contract had been serviced at one of ES’s depots. That depot had looked after just 2 customers. The day shift employees principally carried out work for one customer and the night shift employees for the other customer. ES lost one of the customers (the one serviced by the day shift) and said that there had clearly been a service provision change and that the day shift employees were assigned to the service transferring.

On appeal, the Employment Appeal Tribunal did not agree. It noted the requirement, first and foremost, for an organised grouping of employees and that the fact that the vast majority of the work carried out by the day shift was for that particular customer, did not of itself give rise to them being an organised grouping of employees.

"Taking it first and foremost by reference to the statutory language, regulation 3(3)(a)(i) of TUPE does not say merely that the employees should in their day-to-day work in fact (principally) carry out the activities in question: it says that carrying out those activities should be the (principal) purpose of an organised grouping to which they belong. In my view that necessarily connotes that the employees be organised in some sense by reference to the requirements of the client in question... The paradigm of an "organised grouping" is indeed the case where employees are organised as "the [Client A] team", though no doubt the definition could in principle be satisfied in cases where the identification is less explicit"

This is an important test for contractors to consider, not only at the point of contract review/procurement, but throughout the life of the contract. Is there an expectation, if a contract is lost, that the employees will transfer to a new contractor? If so, how is the workforce organised? Is there a “Client A team” as the paradigm position identified above? If not, is the identification of employees who might be considered as the “organised grouping” more sophisticated than a simple percentage of time spent basis? If not, then it is very unlikely that the definition of a service provision change will be met.

Issue two – who is assigned?

The Eddie Stobart case (above) highlighted the need to identify the relevant transfer before then considering the issue of which employees are assigned to the undertaking/service which is transferring.

The requirement for an employee to be assigned, goes back to the European Acquired Rights Directive from which TUPE originates. A 1985 European court decision (Botzen v. Rotterdamsche Droogdok Maatschappij BV) is still referred to in decisions on this issue. This case decided that only employees who are actually assigned to the department (or service or undertaking) transferring should transfer. It noted that it is not a question of looking at which employees spent all or most of their time but rather deciding to which part of their employing organisation, they are assigned. The applicability of this test was recently noted in the Employment Appeal Tribunal decision of London Borough of Hillingdon v. Gormanley (19 December 2014).

The test is a useful reminder to those who look at which employees should/should not transfer by applying a percentage amount to the work that employees carry out within a transferring service. The application of a percentage is commonplace and has been for a number of years. The percentage levels commonly used, also seem to have declined over the years. For example, under the CCT environment in local government in the 1990’s it was common to see percentages of 75-80% being applied. In the “Learning to Succeed” reforms of the early 2000s (by which Training and Enterprise Councils were abolished and their activities taken up by other bodies, most notably the Learning and Skills Council) the Government issued guidance which referred to a “two thirds principle.” More recently it has not been uncommon to see parties apply a 50 or 55% threshold.

Crucially though, the test of assignment has to be met. Whilst, in general terms, the greater the percentage of time an employee spends working on the service/undertaking which is transferring, the more likely it is that the test will be met, it is clear ( and must be remembered) that it is possible for an employee not to be assigned to a service even though they spend the majority (even the vast majority) of their time working in the service and visa versa.

Some conclusions and suggestions

  • Remember, when looking at service provision changes, that the organised grouping of employees (which has as its principle purpose the carrying out of the service) has to be identified. Otherwise there is no service provision change to which TUPE will apply.
  • Common sense conclusion - those employees who form part of that organised grouping of employees must also meet the definition of assignment.
  • It is possible though that there may be some employees who are not part of that organised grouping who also meet the definition of assignment.
  • Applying a percentage to try to identify the organised grouping of employees would be far too unsophisticated an approach (look at the Eddie Stobart case for example).
  • Applying a percentage to try to identify those employees who are assigned, might serve as a useful guide, but remembering always that it will not in itself determine whether an employee is assigned to the service transferring.

Note - TUPE means the Transfer of Undertaking (Protection of Employment) Regulations 2006.

From My Wiki

Jump to: navigation, search

Do you need help with with essay, research paper, homework or even dissertation?

Visit our website - (

=================>>>CLICK HERE<<<=================
=================>>>CLICK HERE<<<=================
=================>>>CLICK HERE<<<=================

=================>>>GET ASSIGNMENT HELP<<<=================
=================>>>GET ASSIGNMENT HELP<<<=================
=================>>>GET ASSIGNMENT HELP<<<=================

bus 308 week 5 assignment excel
darakhton ke faide essay writer
release patent assignment mpep
essay about tsunami in japan 2011 damage
panasahan folk dance definition essay
cover letter for employment doc
global warming essay kids
game theory bibliography format
leader definition essay on love
plato socrates apology essay
oaklands catholic school show my homework login microsoft
essayer lunette en ligne optic 2000 sxm
a brief essay discussing your view of america
free samples of cover letters for receptionists
com3705 assignment 1 skeletal system
first class dissertation
romeo and juliet alternate ending assignment of rents
daft punk homework vinyl records
definition of strategic management essay
chapter 15 to kill a mockingbird essay
american history to 1877 topics for essays
essays on racism in a lesson before dying spark
why literature matters essay
a level sociology essay help
telephone conversation by wole soyinka analysis essays
promocion fantasma critical thinking
college term papers
celta application essay
glamour magazine essay contest 2012
cmi assignment 7004
persian urdu and pashto a comparative orthographic analysis essay
proper essay format sample
jqplot legend location example essay
nosich 8 elements of critical The Easiest Way to Write an Essay thinking
list of transition words for persuasive essays examples
apply texas essays 2016 prompts
bob harris essay
rotman essay analysis dissertations
critical thinking journal articles
the phoenix and The Easiest Way to Write an Essay turtle poem analysis essays
federalist vs democratic republican essay outline
essay writing on guru purnima image
india thematic essays
euro disney case study recommendations for colonoscopy
my vacations essay
memoir essay conclusion example
hindu muslim sikh isai essay writer
5 paragraph essay mini lesson on context
personal essay topics leaving cert timetable 2016
nair caste scholarship essays
morality of capitalism essay contest for kids
post assignment definition real estate
domostroi essay outline
medical case study templates
shikshak ka mahatva in hindi essay on corruption
clifford asness dissertation meaning
quartus illegal location assignment
dissertation lmu university
how to write a analysis essay thesis
19th century reformers essay
rogerian essay conclusion generator
short essay on election process in india
advantages and disadvantages of big family essay conclusion
dissertation reflections
kate braverman pagan night summary The Easiest Way to Write an Essay essay
wordsworth nature essay emerson
james esl essay topics
format for scholarship application essay
first sentence in a essay
career job shadow reflective essay introduction
hp acquisition of autonomy case study
image cafe case study
case study introduction paragraphs
5th grade math essay questions
radio internship cover letter
research papers on image processing 2013 tx68
automotive b sample definition essays
brutus tragic hero free essay
caninos inferiores e superioressay
4th grade division worksheets homework for kids
ram navami essay in hindi The Easiest Way to Write an Essay language
feminist and womanist essays in reformed dogmatics
brisingr book length bibliography
thesis statement generator owl purdue
personal essays by teenagers
mass media advantages and disadvantages essay
use google research paper
pier 27 toronto assignment sheet
notes on a scandal book essay contest
protein kinase a definition of critical thinking
ghazwa badar The Easiest Way to Write an Essay essay in urdu
dilations and similarity homework answers
sulating pangwakas ang aking pangarap essay
upward bound essay examples
hell and back obstacles to critical thinking
writing a conclusion for an informative essay
hbse open 12th assignment help
abortion research paper outline sample
message to garcia essay pdf
essay abi 2014 impala
south africa racism today essay
marketing research papers 2010
student nurse clinical experience essay
sales cover letter university
giv mig denmark tilbage essay format
ideas for observation essay
yahoo case study 2011 hyundai
classroom assignment tracker printable
essay on metamorphosis
feminist perspective on family essay
effect essay fast food
essays about child prostitution
get band 7 ielts essay
my academic achievement essay
co educational schools essay
five-paragraph expository essay model
definition essay examples for high school student
bedzed case study bbc arabic
ignou ms 26 solved assignment dec 2012 winter
good essay clincher
teachervision sample essay outlines
territory assignment rules in salesforce stock
botzen test of assignment sheet
personal and impersonal statements tile
kid doing homework clip art
dissertation sur la philosophie et la science olympiad
michel eyquem de montaigne essays summaries
counting out rhyme analysis essay
how to cite shakespeare quotes in an essay mla
download english essay book
ap biology essay 1992 rubric examples
the shock master entrance essay
sample cover letter for special education teacher assistant
bcms homework
kalidasa shakuntala essay writing
free nigerian essays
life in 2050 short essay about life
stern review summary of conclusions to essays
social problem in malaysia The Easiest Way to Write an Essay essays on abortion
essay on terrorism in india in simple language meaning
eyjafjallajokull case study responses to death
essays on culture and language
research paper topics corporate governance
philosophy of science a very short introduction summary essay
argentina culture essay anthropology
critical thinking identifying fallacies answers
yin r 2009 case study research design and methods text
dsm case study book
write essay my worst nightmare essay

One thought on “Botzen Test Of Assignment Sheet

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *